What is Business Real Property?

Home – Resources – Property Investments – What is Business Real Property

What is Business Real Property?

What is Business Real PropertyThe term business real property is an important concept in relation to SMSF trustees acquiring assets from, invest in, or enter into lease arrangements with or in relation to related parties.

When an SMSF acquires a property from a related party or leases a property to a related party, the property must meet the definition of “business real property”.

In simple terms business real property means land and buildings used wholly and exclusively in a business.

Business real property is defined under the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (SISA) subsection 66 (5) as:

“business real property, in relation to an entity, means:

(a)  any freehold or leasehold interest of the entity in real property; or

(b)  any interest of the entity in Crown land, other than a leasehold interest, being an interest that is capable of assignment or transfer; or

(c)  if another class of interest in relation to real property is prescribed by the regulations for the purposes of this paragraph – any interest belonging to that class that is held by the entity;

where the real property is used wholly and exclusively in one or more businesses (whether carried on by the entity or not) but does not include any interest held in the capacity of beneficiary of a trust estate.”

Business Real Property Must Satisfy Two Basic Conditions

  1. There must be an eligible interest in property which must be a freehold, leasehold or interests in Crown land in ‘real property’
  2. The property must be ‘used wholly and exclusively in one or more businesses’ carried on by an entity

Real Property

Real property is not defined under SISA and takes on its ordinary meaning. Real property refers to land and includes anything growing on it, attached to it or erected on it such as grapevines (but not the grapes), fruit trees (but not the fruit), buildings, fences and roads. It includes buildings or structures which are immovable or would otherwise significantly damage the land if removed.

Residential, commercial, industrial and vacant land are all types of real property. Plant and equipment, motor vehicles, portable and demountable buildings not permanently attached to the land, water rights and large movable irrigation systems are examples of property which is not real property.

A freehold interest in real property gives the owner the right to possess, sell, lease, and otherwise enjoy the property. Property cannot be dealt with separately.

A leasehold interest in real property provides a right to an entity to exclusive possession of the property for a specific period as determined between the parties which can be the whole of the property or part of the property.

An interest in Crown land (except for a leasehold which is covered by the usual leasehold interest referred to above) must be capable of being assigned or transferred. Crown land is vested in the Commonwealth, State or Territory and is subject to the specific statutes in each jurisdiction. Examples of Crown land includes pastoral, agricultural and mining leases.

Hint – Real property can be co-owned between a SMSF and another party, related or not, as tenants in common allowing each party to hold a freehold interest in the property.

Example – Warehouse on two separate titles – eligible interest in real property

Jo’s SMSF is considering purchasing a warehouse which is situated over two separate titles. Generally, real property has one title. However, the warehouse is a large complex construction and is attached to the land subject to separate titles.  The construction is a unifying physical object attached to the land and is significant in nature and removing it would cause considerable damage and cost. The warehouse would be considered as being real property.

Example – Water Licence – not an eligible interest in real property

Andrew’s SMSF owns land on which his family company conducts a business of primary production. His SMSF wants to purchase the water licence from his family company at market value. The water licence is an entitlement to draw a certain amount of water from the local river. The sale involved the sale of rights and then granting the rights back to the company.  This does not fit the definition of real property and therefore is unable to be acquired from Andrew’s family company.

Example – Commercial unit held under company title – not an eligible interest in real property Michael’s SMSF wants to purchase a unit which can be leased to him as part of his architectural business. Michael is a good quality tenant and market value rent would be charged. The unit is under company title which is a special type of company which owns an office block and allows exclusive possession, by the shareholders, of a specific unit.  Whilst the shares allow the SMSF to give Michael the right to occupy the unit for his business his SMSF does not hold an eligible interest in real property.  His SMSF owns shares in a private company.

Used Wholly and Exclusively in one or more Businesses

We breakdown this further by looking at “is there a business use” and “is the property used wholly and exclusively in one or more businesses”?

Is there a business use?

What is Business Real PropertyFirstly, is there a business? Generally, a hobby farm would not meet the criteria of a business although other farm properties could, nor would selling a few used items over the internet, renting out one or two investment properties or renovating a residential property for profit.

The definition of business under SISA section 66 is:

““business” includes any profession, trade, employment, vocation or calling carried on for the purposes of profit, including:

(a)  the carrying on of primary production; and

(b)  the provision of professional services;

but does not include occupation as an employee”

The ATO look to such factors as size of operation, profit intention, capital involved, keeping of records, the scale and permanency of operations and continuous and systematic activities. Refer to SMSFR 2009/1 para 117 and Tax Ruling 97/11 (para 23 to 93) for further details:

Real property must be used in one or more businesses at the time it is acquired from a related party or when it is leased to a related party.  It can be used by a related party business or any other business. The property is only required to be used, at least, in a business.

Vacant land utilised in a business context can satisfy the business use test. For instance, vacant land held as inventory by a developer is generally considered part of their land development operations. Similarly, a freight company that owns a vacant lot adjacent to their establishment uses it for parking their large semi-trailers may also meet the criteria for the business use test.

Business use includes the use of the property to carry out the business for its core activities such as stockpiling goods in a warehouse, an office space used for the activities of an accountant or a solicitor, a hairdressing salon or a shop selling retail goods or a café. It can also include incidental and relevant activities to the business which the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) have provided examples including:

  • permitting employees to park their cars on business premises;
  • allowing or requiring a security guard to sleep on business premises; and
  • allowing or requiring managers or employees to reside at the business premises where 24 hour ‘on call’ service is contemplated by the activities of the business, such as in the case of a hotel or a motel and;
  • granting of rights to guests to use the facilities and accommodation of a hotel, motel and other similar short-term accommodation.

Hint: The ATO consider the business use test is only met when the entity granting guests the right to use the facilities of a hotel or similar short-term accommodations is carrying on a business.

Hint: Generally, the use of property by residential tenants is not part of a business except in the circumstances where the landlord is leasing residential property in carrying on a business which is not common to SMSFs.

Example – SMSF does not meet the business use test

Jim owns a unit in a unit complex on the Gold Coast. It is an investment property, and he doesn’t use the property. The holiday rental and related expenses are managed by Gold Coast Holiday Rentals Pty Ltd. The company carry on a business as they manage all of the units in the Gold Coast complex except for a few which are occupied by the owners. Jim wanted to sell the unit to his SMSF as it provided good returns and had a high occupancy rate. Unfortunately, he is unable to do this as Jim does not carry on a business and therefore the business use test would fail.

Example – Doctor’s surgery in residential premises – business real property

Jane carries on a medical practice from a residential home which is used 100% as a medical practice with no private use. Jane wants to sell it to her SMSF at market value. She is able to do this. Whilst the premises are residential it is the use of the premises as a medical practice business which enables the property to meet the business use criteria.

The property is not required to be zoned commercial to meet the business use test. In fact, a vacant building zoned commercial which is not used in a business will not meet the business use test.

Example: Subleasing – business real property (from SMSFR 2009/1)

Caleb’s Constructions Pty Ltd, the owner of a factory, grants a lease to Martin Industries Pty Ltd for exclusive possession of the premises.

The lease is for a period of 6 years. There are no terms in the agreement preventing sublease or assignment. Martin Industries occupies the premises for 1 year. At this time, Martin Industries grants exclusive possession of the premises to Tilla’s Trucks Pty Ltd for a period of 3 years. At the end of the 3-year period, Martin Industries occupies the premises for the remaining 2 years. Both Martin Industries and Tilla’s Trucks conduct a business from the factory premises.

The arrangement between Martin Industries and Tilla’s Trucks is a sublease of the property. This is because Martin Industries has disposed of less than its full interest in the property by granting Tilla’s Trucks a right to exclusive possession of the premises for only some of the remaining time that it was entitled to possession under the lease.

As a consequence of the use of the property by Martin Industries and Tilla’s Trucks’, the business use test is satisfied. At all relevant times, the freehold interest in the property held by Caleb’s Constructions and the leasehold interests in the property held by Martin Industries and Tilla’s Trucks are business real property of each of those entities. In addition, Caleb’s Constructions Pty Ltd.’s freehold interest is business real property. Note that Tilla’s Trucks’ leasehold interest is only its business real property for the 3-year period that the company holds that interest.

Is the property used wholly and exclusively in one or more businesses?

The ATO’s view is that the “wholly and exclusive use” is a single test.

It is not meant to be a literal understanding of the words but rather a more common-sense approach is taken by the ATO.

The word “wholly” is not meant to exclude minor, insignificant or trifling non-business use of the property. Minor non-business use of the property will not fail the business use test. The word “exclusively” looks to whether the business use of the property is to the exclusion of any other use. The property has to be used to some appreciable degree in one or more businesses.

Example – Vacant land not business real property

Paul and Alia own a vacant block of land which is zoned as commercial land. They allow their son Dillon to park his truck and excavator on the vacant land. Dillon uses the truck and machinery in his business as a landscape gardener. Dillon does not pay his parents for the use of the land and there is no lease between them. Paul and Alia have asked if they can sell their vacant block of land to their SMSF.

The vacant block of land is real property, but it is not used wholly and exclusively in any business. The zoning of the land does not impact on the business use test. Dillon does not have any exclusive right to use the vacant land as he has no lease with his parents. It fails the business use test.

Example – Property not used 100% for factory – is business real property
A factory is constructed on land and used 100% to manufacture various horse related products. Not all of the land was used as a minor amount of the land was left vacant to be used for future expansion. The property is used to an appreciable degree in the manufacturing business. The property is eligible as business real property as it satisfies the business use test.

There is a special carve for primary production business which can include residential and business use.

“Subsection 66(6) specifically addresses the application of the ‘wholly and exclusively’ test to real property used in a primary production business on which there is a dwelling and/or area of the land used primarily for domestic or private purposes. Where the area used primarily for domestic or private purposes does not exceed 2 hectares, and the use of the property for domestic or private purposes is not considered to be the predominant use of the property, the real property is still considered to be used ‘wholly and exclusively’ in a primary production business. A property meeting these conditions will therefore be regarded as business real property for the purposes of section 66.”

Example -Primary production business with a private residence – is business real property

ATO SMSFR 2009/1

The Harrison Vineyard is owned and managed by Peter and Denise Harrison who are members of the Harrison SMSF. The property has 10 hectares planted out with vines and on half a hectare of the property they have built a private residence in which they live.

The vineyard business has a grape supply agreement with a local winery for the next 5 years. This agreement forms the basis of a business of primary production that is being conducted on the property. The Harrison SMSF acquires the property (not including the grape supply agreement) from Peter and Denise at its market value. Peter and Denise then lease the property from the SMSF.

The property is business real property of both the Harrison SMSF after it acquires the property and of Peter and Denise at all times. At all relevant times, the Harrison SMSF and Peter and Denise hold either a freehold interest in the land or a leasehold interest in the land. The use of the private residence is permitted under the specific application of the ‘wholly and exclusively’ test in subsection 66(6). Therefore, the property is used wholly and exclusively in Peter and Denise’s business at all times.

Accordingly:

the acquisition of property by the Harrison SMSF from Peter and Denise does not contravene the related party asset acquisition rule in section 66; and

the freehold interest in the property is not an in-house asset of the Harrison SMSF under Part 8.

The vines form part of the real property.

Timing Matters

What is Business Real PropertyTiming is crucial in relation to applying the business use test. When acquiring real property from a related party the business use test is applied at the time of acquisition.  The business use test is not required if the property is purchased from an unrelated party but must be applied when a related party leases a property from the SMSF.

The ATO do not take a narrow view but look at all of the circumstances in relation to the application of the business use test. Commercial land which historically has been used in a business and is temporarily vacant whilst another tenant is being sought will not necessarily fail the test unless the owner changes their plans and ceases to lease the property.

In contrast land which is used by a business on a short-term basis at the time of acquisition to enable a SMSF to meet the business use test will fail the business use test.

Key Takeaways

  • The use of property by a related party must meet the “Business Real Property” definition
  • There are two basic conditions to satisfy the criteria of “Business Real Property” being an interest in “Real Property” and the property must be used “Wholly and Exclusively in one or more Businesses”
  • Real property is anything attached to the land or is not easily removed
  • Consider if there is a business
  • Is the property used wholly or substantially by the business?
  • Is the business use of the property excluding other uses?
  • Timing in applying the business use test is critical

Do you want to learn more about Business Real Property?

Give us a call on 1300 392 544 or get in touch online.

Contact Us

If you’re interested in learning more about Business Real Property please reach out to us. Simply submit your details and one of our friendly team will be in touch as soon as possible.

Contact Us

Name(Required)

Search SMSF Australia